The Scribe’s Advantage

From the book

Manuscripts by Century

Manuscripts produced in Western Europe, sixth to fifteenth century, and the printed books that followed

Buringh and Van Zanden charted manuscript production across the Latin West from the sixth century to the fifteenth. The book keeps three of its numbers: about eleven thousand in the seventh century, five million in the fifteenth, and some twelve and a half million printed books from 1454 to 1500. This is the whole curve.

Supports Chapter 13, “Latin: A Republic of Letters Across Borders and Time.” The printed book points here for the detail it no longer carries.

The curve

  • 6th14,000
  • 7th11,000
  • 8th44,000
  • 9th200,000
  • 10th140,000
  • 11th210,000
  • 12th770,000
  • 13th1,800,000
  • 14th2,700,000
  • 15th5,000,000
  • 1454 to 1500about 12,600,000

Gold: manuscripts copied by hand, per century. Blue: printed books in the incunabula period alone, forty-six years. Bars share one linear scale.

The table

CenturyManuscripts producedWhat was happening
6th14,000Rome’s shadow; monasteries founding
7th11,000The floor: the darkest century
8th44,000Carolingian recovery begins
9th200,000Carolingian peak
10th140,000The dip
11th210,000Recovery; Bologna founded 1088
12th770,000Universities; the market takes over from the scriptorium
13th1,800,000Twenty universities by 1300
14th2,700,000Plague century, and still climbing
15th5,000,000Sixty-six universities by 1500
1454 to 1500plus roughly 12,600,000 printed booksGutenberg

The three numbers the book keeps

Western Europe copied about eleven thousand manuscripts in the seventh century, the floor, the darkest century, when even the monasteries nearly stopped writing. By the fifteenth century it was five million. The incunabula period alone, 1454 to 1500, put out some twelve and a half million printed books, more than twice as many copies as all manuscript production in the entire fifteenth century.